Discrete mixture with panel data

Example of a discrete mixture of logit models, also called latent

class model. The datafile is organized as panel data. Compared to Discrete mixture with panel data, we integrate before the discrete mixture to show that it is equivalent.

author:

Michel Bierlaire, EPFL

date:

Mon Apr 10 11:55:26 2023

import biogeme.biogeme_logging as blog
import biogeme.biogeme as bio
from biogeme import models
from biogeme.expressions import (
    Beta,
    bioDraws,
    PanelLikelihoodTrajectory,
    MonteCarlo,
    log,
    ExpressionOrNumeric,
)
from biogeme.parameters import Parameters

See the data processing script: Panel data preparation for Swissmetro.

from swissmetro_panel import (
    database,
    CHOICE,
    SM_AV,
    CAR_AV_SP,
    TRAIN_AV_SP,
    TRAIN_TT_SCALED,
    TRAIN_COST_SCALED,
    SM_TT_SCALED,
    SM_COST_SCALED,
    CAR_TT_SCALED,
    CAR_CO_SCALED,
)

logger = blog.get_screen_logger(level=blog.INFO)
logger.info('Example b15panel_discrete_bis.py')
Example b15panel_discrete_bis.py

Parameters to be estimated. One version for each latent class.

NUMBER_OF_CLASSES = 2
B_COST = [Beta(f'B_COST_class{i}', 0, None, None, 0) for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)]

Define a random parameter, normally distributed across individuals, designed to be used for Monte-Carlo simulation.

B_TIME = [Beta(f'B_TIME_class{i}', 0, None, None, 0) for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)]

It is advised not to use 0 as starting value for the following parameter.

B_TIME_S = [
    Beta(f'B_TIME_S_class{i}', 1, None, None, 0) for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]
B_TIME_RND: list[ExpressionOrNumeric] = [
    B_TIME[i] + B_TIME_S[i] * bioDraws(f'B_TIME_RND_class{i}', 'NORMAL_ANTI')
    for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]

We do the same for the constants, to address serial correlation.

ASC_CAR = [
    Beta(f'ASC_CAR_class{i}', 0, None, None, 0) for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]
ASC_CAR_S = [
    Beta(f'ASC_CAR_S_class{i}', 1, None, None, 0) for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]
ASC_CAR_RND = [
    ASC_CAR[i] + ASC_CAR_S[i] * bioDraws(f'ASC_CAR_RND_class{i}', 'NORMAL_ANTI')
    for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]

ASC_TRAIN = [
    Beta(f'ASC_TRAIN_class{i}', 0, None, None, 0) for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]
ASC_TRAIN_S = [
    Beta(f'ASC_TRAIN_S_class{i}', 1, None, None, 0) for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]
ASC_TRAIN_RND = [
    ASC_TRAIN[i] + ASC_TRAIN_S[i] * bioDraws(f'ASC_TRAIN_RND_class{i}', 'NORMAL_ANTI')
    for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]

ASC_SM = [Beta(f'ASC_SM_class{i}', 0, None, None, 1) for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)]
ASC_SM_S = [
    Beta(f'ASC_SM_S_class{i}', 1, None, None, 0) for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]
ASC_SM_RND = [
    ASC_SM[i] + ASC_SM_S[i] * bioDraws(f'ASC_SM_RND_class{i}', 'NORMAL_ANTI')
    for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]

Class memebership probability.

prob_class0 = Beta('prob_class0', 0.5, 0, 1, 0)
prob_class1 = 1 - prob_class0

In class 0, it is assumed that the time coefficient is zero.

B_TIME_RND[0] = 0

Utility functions.

V1 = [
    ASC_TRAIN_RND[i] + B_TIME_RND[i] * TRAIN_TT_SCALED + B_COST[i] * TRAIN_COST_SCALED
    for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]
V2 = [
    ASC_SM_RND[i] + B_TIME_RND[i] * SM_TT_SCALED + B_COST[i] * SM_COST_SCALED
    for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]
V3 = [
    ASC_CAR_RND[i] + B_TIME_RND[i] * CAR_TT_SCALED + B_COST[i] * CAR_CO_SCALED
    for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]
V = [{1: V1[i], 2: V2[i], 3: V3[i]} for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)]

Associate the availability conditions with the alternatives

av = {1: TRAIN_AV_SP, 2: SM_AV, 3: CAR_AV_SP}

The choice model is a discrete mixture of logit, with availability conditions We calculate the conditional probability for each class.

prob = [
    MonteCarlo(PanelLikelihoodTrajectory(models.logit(V[i], av, CHOICE)))
    for i in range(NUMBER_OF_CLASSES)
]

Conditional to the random variables, likelihood for the individual.

probIndiv = prob_class0 * prob[0] + prob_class1 * prob[1]

We integrate over the random variables using Monte-Carlo.

logprob = log(probIndiv)

As the objective is to illustrate the syntax, we calculate the Monte-Carlo approximation with a small number of draws.

the_biogeme = bio.BIOGEME(database, logprob, number_of_draws=100, seed=1223)
the_biogeme.modelName = 'b15panel_discrete_bis'
Biogeme parameters read from biogeme.toml.

Estimate the parameters.

results = the_biogeme.estimate()
As the model is rather complex, we cancel the calculation of second derivatives. If you want to control the parameters, change the name of the algorithm in the TOML file from "automatic" to "simple_bounds"
*** Initial values of the parameters are obtained from the file __b15panel_discrete_bis.iter
Cannot read file __b15panel_discrete_bis.iter. Statement is ignored.
The number of draws (100) is low. The results may not be meaningful.
As the model is rather complex, we cancel the calculation of second derivatives. If you want to control the parameters, change the name of the algorithm in the TOML file from "automatic" to "simple_bounds"
Optimization algorithm: hybrid Newton/BFGS with simple bounds [simple_bounds]
** Optimization: BFGS with trust region for simple bounds
Iter. ASC_CAR_S_class ASC_CAR_S_class  ASC_CAR_class0  ASC_CAR_class1 ASC_SM_S_class0 ASC_SM_S_class1 ASC_TRAIN_S_cla ASC_TRAIN_S_cla ASC_TRAIN_class ASC_TRAIN_class   B_COST_class0   B_COST_class1 B_TIME_S_class1   B_TIME_class1     prob_class0     Function    Relgrad   Radius      Rho
    0               2               2               1               1               2               2               2               2              -1              -1              -1              -1               2              -1         5.6e-17        4e+03      0.033        1     0.46    +
    1               2               2               1               1               2               2               2               2              -1              -1              -1              -1               2              -1         5.6e-17        4e+03      0.033      0.5    0.036    -
    2               2             1.5               1             0.5               2             1.5               2             1.5              -1            -1.5              -1            -1.5             2.5            -1.5         5.6e-17      3.9e+03      0.026      0.5     0.61    +
    3               2             1.5               1            0.28               2             1.5               2             1.5              -1            -1.6              -1            -1.7             2.7              -2         3.2e-05      3.8e+03      0.024      0.5     0.24    +
    4               2               2            0.99          -0.032             1.9             1.7               2             1.9           -0.97            -1.2              -1              -2             2.8            -2.4         3.1e-05      3.8e+03      0.027      0.5     0.66    +
    5               2             2.2            0.98            0.18             1.9             1.6             2.1               2           -0.94            -1.3              -1            -2.4             2.8            -2.9         3.2e-05      3.7e+03      0.017      0.5     0.67    +
    6             2.1             2.7            0.96            0.15             1.8             1.6             2.1             2.3           -0.89              -1            -1.1            -2.5               3            -3.4         3.1e-05      3.7e+03      0.026        5      1.2   ++
    7             2.1             2.7            0.96            0.15             1.8             1.6             2.1             2.3           -0.89              -1            -1.1            -2.5               3            -3.4         3.1e-05      3.7e+03      0.026      2.5     -1.1    -
    8             2.3             3.6            0.82            0.26             1.3             1.8             2.4             2.8           -0.64           -0.16           -0.97            -3.2             3.4            -5.9         2.9e-05      3.6e+03      0.026      2.5     0.84    +
    9             2.3             3.6            0.82            0.26             1.3             1.8             2.4             2.8           -0.64           -0.16           -0.97            -3.2             3.4            -5.9         2.9e-05      3.6e+03      0.026      1.2     -0.4    -
   10             2.3             3.6            0.82            0.26             1.3             1.8             2.4             2.8           -0.64           -0.16           -0.97            -3.2             3.4            -5.9         2.9e-05      3.6e+03      0.026     0.62    -0.34    -
   11             2.3             3.6             0.8             0.6             1.4             1.7             2.4             2.4           -0.63           -0.46            -0.9            -3.4             4.1            -5.5         3.1e-05      3.6e+03     0.0073     0.62     0.16    +
   12             2.3             3.6             0.8             0.6             1.4             1.7             2.4             2.4           -0.63           -0.46            -0.9            -3.4             4.1            -5.5         3.1e-05      3.6e+03     0.0073     0.31     -1.8    -
   13             2.4             3.6            0.77            0.32             1.4             1.4             2.4             2.1            -0.6           -0.42            -0.8            -3.2               4            -5.8         2.8e-05      3.6e+03      0.034     0.31      0.2    +
   14             2.4             3.6            0.77            0.32             1.4             1.4             2.4             2.1            -0.6           -0.42            -0.8            -3.2               4            -5.8         2.8e-05      3.6e+03      0.034     0.16    0.039    -
   15             2.4             3.6            0.76            0.36             1.4             1.5             2.4             2.1            -0.6           -0.38            -0.8            -3.2             4.1            -5.6         2.8e-05      3.6e+03      0.023     0.16     0.27    +
   16             2.4             3.6            0.75            0.45             1.4             1.5             2.5             2.1           -0.58           -0.23            -0.8            -3.4               4            -5.7           3e-05      3.6e+03      0.009     0.16     0.61    +
   17             2.4             3.6            0.75            0.45             1.4             1.5             2.5             2.1           -0.58           -0.23            -0.8            -3.4               4            -5.7           3e-05      3.6e+03      0.009    0.078   -0.066    -
   18             2.4             3.7            0.73            0.43             1.3             1.5             2.5               2           -0.56           -0.28           -0.79            -3.3               4            -5.7         2.9e-05      3.6e+03     0.0017    0.078     0.77    +
   19             2.4             3.7            0.73            0.43             1.3             1.5             2.5               2           -0.56           -0.28           -0.79            -3.3               4            -5.7         2.9e-05      3.6e+03     0.0017    0.039    -0.51    -
   20             2.4             3.7            0.73            0.43             1.3             1.5             2.5               2           -0.55           -0.28           -0.78            -3.3               4            -5.7         2.9e-05      3.6e+03     0.0022    0.039     0.82    +
   21             2.4             3.7            0.73            0.43             1.3             1.5             2.5               2           -0.55           -0.28           -0.78            -3.3               4            -5.7         2.9e-05      3.6e+03     0.0022     0.02   -0.013    -
   22             2.5             3.7            0.72            0.43             1.3             1.5             2.5               2           -0.54           -0.26           -0.78            -3.3               4            -5.7         2.9e-05      3.6e+03     0.0054     0.02      0.2    +
   23             2.5             3.7            0.71            0.43             1.3             1.5             2.5               2           -0.53           -0.26           -0.77            -3.3               4            -5.7           3e-05      3.6e+03    0.00055      0.2        1   ++
   24             2.6             3.7            0.63            0.42             1.3             1.7             2.5             1.8           -0.44           -0.25           -0.73            -3.4             4.1            -5.8           3e-05      3.6e+03     0.0014        2      2.5   ++
   25             2.6             3.7            0.63            0.42             1.3             1.7             2.5             1.8           -0.44           -0.25           -0.73            -3.4             4.1            -5.8           3e-05      3.6e+03     0.0014     0.98     -3.7    -
   26             2.6             3.7            0.63            0.42             1.3             1.7             2.5             1.8           -0.44           -0.25           -0.73            -3.4             4.1            -5.8           3e-05      3.6e+03     0.0014     0.49       -1    -
   27             2.7             3.6            0.58            0.31             1.3             2.1             2.5             1.4           -0.39           -0.16           -0.72            -3.5             4.1            -5.8         3.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0051      4.9     0.98   ++
   28             2.7             3.6            0.58            0.31             1.3             2.1             2.5             1.4           -0.39           -0.16           -0.72            -3.5             4.1            -5.8         3.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0051      2.4     -6.8    -
   29             2.7             3.6            0.58            0.31             1.3             2.1             2.5             1.4           -0.39           -0.16           -0.72            -3.5             4.1            -5.8         3.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0051      1.2     -1.2    -
   30             2.7             3.6            0.58            0.31             1.3             2.1             2.5             1.4           -0.39           -0.16           -0.72            -3.5             4.1            -5.8         3.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0051     0.61     -0.2    -
   31             2.7             3.6            0.58            0.31             1.3             2.1             2.5             1.4           -0.39           -0.16           -0.72            -3.5             4.1            -5.8         3.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0051     0.31    0.095    -
   32             2.8             3.8            0.54            0.25             1.3               2             2.5             1.1           -0.35           -0.31           -0.72            -3.4             4.1            -5.9         3.1e-05      3.6e+03     0.0063     0.31     0.61    +
   33             2.9             3.9            0.52            0.25             1.4             1.9             2.5            0.85           -0.33          -0.093           -0.74            -3.7             4.2            -5.9         3.1e-05      3.6e+03     0.0078     0.31     0.82    +
   34             2.9               4             0.5            0.33             1.4             2.2             2.5            0.54           -0.31           -0.02           -0.74            -3.7             4.2            -5.9         3.3e-05      3.6e+03     0.0064     0.31     0.47    +
   35             2.9             3.8            0.48            0.28             1.4               2             2.5            0.24           -0.29           0.057           -0.74            -3.8             4.2            -6.1         3.2e-05      3.6e+03      0.015     0.31     0.68    +
   36               3               4            0.47            0.25             1.4               2             2.5          -0.067           -0.27            0.06            -0.7            -3.8             4.3            -6.1         3.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0042     0.31     0.42    +
   37               3               4            0.47            0.25             1.4               2             2.5          -0.067           -0.27            0.06            -0.7            -3.8             4.3            -6.1         3.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0042     0.15    -0.14    -
   38             3.1             3.9            0.47            0.25             1.4             2.2             2.5          -0.052           -0.25          -0.029           -0.68            -3.9             4.3            -6.1         3.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0015     0.15     0.66    +
   39             3.1             3.9            0.47            0.25             1.4             2.2             2.5          -0.052           -0.25          -0.029           -0.68            -3.9             4.3            -6.1         3.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0015    0.076    -0.49    -
   40             3.2             3.9            0.47            0.17             1.3             2.1             2.5            -0.1           -0.23           0.016           -0.65            -3.9             4.3            -6.2         3.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0015    0.076     0.43    +
   41             3.2               4            0.47            0.25             1.3             2.1             2.5           -0.13           -0.22         -0.0081           -0.61            -3.9             4.3            -6.1         3.3e-05      3.6e+03     0.0039    0.076     0.55    +
   42             3.3             3.9            0.47            0.21             1.3             2.2             2.5           -0.16            -0.2          0.0045           -0.57            -3.9             4.3            -6.1         3.3e-05      3.6e+03      0.002    0.076     0.76    +
   43             3.4             3.9            0.47            0.18             1.3             2.2             2.4           -0.21           -0.19          -0.026           -0.52            -3.9             4.3            -6.2         3.3e-05      3.6e+03      0.002    0.076     0.65    +
   44             3.4               4            0.47            0.23             1.3             2.2             2.4           -0.28           -0.17           0.015           -0.49            -3.9             4.3            -6.1         3.4e-05      3.6e+03     0.0016    0.076     0.83    +
   45             3.5             3.9            0.47            0.21             1.2             2.2             2.4           -0.35           -0.16          -0.026           -0.46            -3.9             4.3            -6.1         3.4e-05      3.6e+03     0.0018     0.76     0.95   ++
   46             3.5             3.9            0.47            0.21             1.2             2.2             2.4           -0.35           -0.16          -0.026           -0.46            -3.9             4.3            -6.1         3.4e-05      3.6e+03     0.0018     0.38     -5.2    -
   47             3.5             3.9            0.47            0.21             1.2             2.2             2.4           -0.35           -0.16          -0.026           -0.46            -3.9             4.3            -6.1         3.4e-05      3.6e+03     0.0018     0.19     -1.4    -
   48             3.6             3.9            0.47            0.19             1.2             2.1             2.4           -0.54           -0.15         -0.0032           -0.44            -3.9             4.3            -6.1         3.5e-05      3.6e+03     0.0025     0.19     0.19    +
   49             3.6             3.9            0.47            0.19             1.2             2.1             2.4           -0.54           -0.15         -0.0032           -0.44            -3.9             4.3            -6.1         3.5e-05      3.6e+03     0.0025    0.095     -0.7    -
   50             3.7             3.9            0.48            0.26             1.2             2.2             2.4           -0.54           -0.15          -0.052           -0.44            -3.9             4.3            -6.1         3.6e-05      3.6e+03     0.0032    0.095     0.57    +
   51             3.7             3.8            0.48            0.23             1.2             2.2             2.3           -0.55           -0.15          -0.064           -0.44            -3.9             4.3            -6.1         3.7e-05      3.6e+03     0.0026    0.095     0.35    +
   52             3.8             3.9            0.48            0.22             1.2             2.2             2.3           -0.65           -0.14           -0.04           -0.45            -3.9             4.2            -6.1         3.7e-05      3.6e+03    0.00062    0.095     0.75    +
   53             3.9             3.8            0.48            0.26             1.2             2.2             2.3           -0.62           -0.14          -0.057           -0.46            -3.9             4.2              -6         3.8e-05      3.6e+03     0.0013     0.95     0.96   ++
   54             3.9             3.8            0.48            0.26             1.2             2.2             2.3           -0.62           -0.14          -0.057           -0.46            -3.9             4.2              -6         3.8e-05      3.6e+03     0.0013     0.48     -3.5    -
   55             3.9             3.8            0.48            0.26             1.2             2.2             2.3           -0.62           -0.14          -0.057           -0.46            -3.9             4.2              -6         3.8e-05      3.6e+03     0.0013     0.24    -0.36    -
   56             4.1             3.8            0.48            0.24             1.1             2.3             2.2           -0.73           -0.15          -0.089            -0.5            -3.9             4.2              -6         3.9e-05      3.6e+03     0.0017     0.24      0.5    +
   57             4.1             3.8            0.48            0.24             1.1             2.3             2.2           -0.73           -0.15          -0.089            -0.5            -3.9             4.2              -6         3.9e-05      3.6e+03     0.0017     0.12     -1.9    -
   58             4.1             3.8            0.48            0.24             1.1             2.3             2.2           -0.73           -0.15          -0.089            -0.5            -3.9             4.2              -6         3.9e-05      3.6e+03     0.0017     0.06    0.086    -
   59             4.1             3.8            0.48            0.25             1.1             2.2             2.2           -0.71           -0.15          -0.096            -0.5            -3.9             4.2              -6           4e-05      3.6e+03     0.0013      0.6      1.1   ++
   60             4.1             3.8            0.48            0.25             1.1             2.2             2.2           -0.71           -0.15          -0.096            -0.5            -3.9             4.2              -6           4e-05      3.6e+03     0.0013      0.3     -1.5    -
   61             4.4             3.8            0.47            0.25             1.1             2.2               2           -0.56           -0.17          -0.062           -0.52            -3.8             4.2            -5.9           4e-05      3.6e+03     0.0016      0.3     0.36    +
   62             4.4             3.8            0.47            0.25             1.1             2.2               2           -0.56           -0.17          -0.062           -0.52            -3.8             4.2            -5.9           4e-05      3.6e+03     0.0016     0.15    -0.52    -
   63             4.6             3.8            0.47            0.22             1.1             2.2               2           -0.63           -0.18            -0.1           -0.56              -4             4.2              -6         4.1e-05      3.6e+03     0.0027     0.15     0.59    +
   64             4.6             3.8            0.47            0.22             1.1             2.2               2           -0.63           -0.18            -0.1           -0.56              -4             4.2              -6         4.1e-05      3.6e+03     0.0027    0.075    -0.56    -
   65             4.6             3.9            0.47            0.21             1.1             2.2               2           -0.65           -0.18          -0.095           -0.56            -3.9             4.2              -6         4.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0016    0.075     0.62    +
   66             4.6             3.8            0.47            0.29             1.1             2.2             1.9           -0.67            -0.2          -0.067           -0.57            -3.9             4.2              -6         4.3e-05      3.6e+03    0.00043    0.075     0.79    +
   67             4.7             3.8            0.47            0.22             1.1             2.2             1.9           -0.65           -0.22            -0.1           -0.58            -3.9             4.2              -6         4.5e-05      3.6e+03     0.0012     0.75        1   ++
   68             5.5             3.9            0.44            0.29            0.94             2.2             1.5           -0.52           -0.36          -0.069           -0.72            -3.9             4.3            -6.2         4.8e-05      3.6e+03     0.0034     0.75      0.8    +
   69             5.5             3.9            0.44            0.29            0.94             2.2             1.5           -0.52           -0.36          -0.069           -0.72            -3.9             4.3            -6.2         4.8e-05      3.6e+03     0.0034     0.37     -3.6    -
   70             5.5             3.9            0.44            0.29            0.94             2.2             1.5           -0.52           -0.36          -0.069           -0.72            -3.9             4.3            -6.2         4.8e-05      3.6e+03     0.0034     0.19    -0.92    -
   71             5.6             3.8            0.45            0.26            0.94             2.2             1.4           -0.49           -0.41          -0.047           -0.72            -3.9             4.2              -6         5.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0014     0.19     0.77    +
   72             5.6             3.9            0.45            0.15            0.95             2.2             1.4           -0.68           -0.44           -0.13           -0.72            -3.9             4.2              -6         5.6e-05      3.6e+03     0.0021     0.19      0.5    +
   73             5.8             3.8            0.47            0.27            0.95             2.2             1.2           -0.69           -0.55          -0.065           -0.76            -3.8             4.2              -6         5.9e-05      3.6e+03      0.002     0.19     0.75    +
   74               6             3.8            0.49            0.25            0.91             2.2               1           -0.76           -0.61           -0.11           -0.72            -3.9             4.2              -6         6.3e-05      3.6e+03     0.0014      1.9      1.1   ++
   75               6             3.8            0.49            0.25            0.91             2.2               1           -0.76           -0.61           -0.11           -0.72            -3.9             4.2              -6         6.3e-05      3.6e+03     0.0014     0.93     -1.3    -
   76               6             3.8            0.49            0.25            0.91             2.2               1           -0.76           -0.61           -0.11           -0.72            -3.9             4.2              -6         6.3e-05      3.6e+03     0.0014     0.47    -0.69    -
   77             6.5               4            0.42           0.097            0.72             2.2            0.73           -0.37           -0.82          -0.088           -0.75              -4             4.3            -6.1         7.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0024     0.47      0.2    +
   78             6.9             3.9            0.43            0.18            0.59             2.1            0.52           -0.54            -1.1          -0.075           -0.46            -3.9             4.2            -5.9         8.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0014      4.7      1.2   ++
   79             6.9             3.9            0.43            0.18            0.59             2.1            0.52           -0.54            -1.1          -0.075           -0.46            -3.9             4.2            -5.9         8.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0014      2.3       -4    -
   80             6.9             3.9            0.43            0.18            0.59             2.1            0.52           -0.54            -1.1          -0.075           -0.46            -3.9             4.2            -5.9         8.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0014      1.2     -1.8    -
   81             6.9             3.9            0.43            0.18            0.59             2.1            0.52           -0.54            -1.1          -0.075           -0.46            -3.9             4.2            -5.9         8.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0014     0.58     -1.2    -
   82             6.9             3.9            0.43            0.18            0.59             2.1            0.52           -0.54            -1.1          -0.075           -0.46            -3.9             4.2            -5.9         8.2e-05      3.6e+03     0.0014     0.29   -0.099    -
   83             7.1             3.8             0.4            0.32            0.44             2.2            0.33           -0.83            -1.2          -0.064           -0.73            -3.9             4.2            -6.1         8.8e-05      3.6e+03     0.0017     0.29     0.51    +
   84             7.3             3.8            0.35            0.25            0.31             2.2            0.23           -0.71            -1.5          -0.086           -0.57            -3.9             4.2              -6         9.6e-05      3.6e+03     0.0013      2.9      1.1   ++
   85             7.3             3.8            0.35            0.25            0.31             2.2            0.23           -0.71            -1.5          -0.086           -0.57            -3.9             4.2              -6         9.6e-05      3.6e+03     0.0013      1.5    -0.28    -
   86             7.3             3.8            0.35            0.25            0.31             2.2            0.23           -0.71            -1.5          -0.086           -0.57            -3.9             4.2              -6         9.6e-05      3.6e+03     0.0013     0.73    -0.74    -
   87               8             3.6           0.062            0.23           -0.29             2.1           -0.19           -0.78            -2.1           -0.17            -1.2            -3.8               4            -5.8         0.00012      3.6e+03     0.0043     0.73     0.62    +
   88             8.7             3.7            -0.6            0.34           -0.92             2.3           -0.49            -0.8            -2.9           -0.12            -1.2              -4             4.2              -6         0.00014      3.6e+03     0.0036      7.3      1.2   ++
   89              11             3.4            -3.3            0.63            -1.7             2.4            -1.1            -1.4            -4.9           -0.19            -1.6            -4.2             4.3            -6.1         0.00023      3.6e+03     0.0068      7.3     0.48    +
   90              12             3.3            -2.6             0.6           -0.77             2.2            -1.3            -1.7            -6.3           -0.35            -2.3            -4.1             4.1            -5.9         0.00025      3.6e+03      0.003       73      0.9   ++
   91              12             3.3            -2.6             0.6           -0.77             2.2            -1.3            -1.7            -6.3           -0.35            -2.3            -4.1             4.1            -5.9         0.00025      3.6e+03      0.003      1.7     -1.5    -
   92              12             3.3            -2.6             0.6           -0.77             2.2            -1.3            -1.7            -6.3           -0.35            -2.3            -4.1             4.1            -5.9         0.00025      3.6e+03      0.003     0.85     -1.1    -
   93              12             3.3            -2.6             0.6           -0.77             2.2            -1.3            -1.7            -6.3           -0.35            -2.3            -4.1             4.1            -5.9         0.00025      3.6e+03      0.003     0.43    -0.96    -
   94              12             3.3            -2.6             0.6           -0.77             2.2            -1.3            -1.7            -6.3           -0.35            -2.3            -4.1             4.1            -5.9         0.00025      3.6e+03      0.003     0.21    -0.53    -
   95              12             3.5            -2.6            0.53           -0.79               2            -1.3            -1.6            -6.3            -0.4            -2.3            -4.1             4.1            -5.9         0.00026      3.6e+03       0.01     0.21     0.62    +
   96              12             3.5            -2.7            0.46           -0.94             1.9            -1.2            -1.8            -6.1           -0.42            -2.2            -4.1             3.9            -5.6         0.00028      3.6e+03     0.0044     0.21     0.88    +
   97              12             3.4              -3            0.53            -1.1             1.9            -1.2            -1.6              -6           -0.32            -2.1              -4             3.9            -5.6         0.00029      3.6e+03     0.0042      2.1      1.1   ++
   98              13             3.5            -4.4            0.54            -1.3             1.8            -1.2            -1.7            -5.3           -0.32            -2.1            -4.2               4            -5.7         0.00033      3.6e+03     0.0029      2.1      0.7    +
   99              13             3.5            -4.6            0.56           -0.87             1.8           -0.23            -1.7            -5.2            -0.3            -2.5            -4.2             4.1            -5.8         0.00035      3.6e+03     0.0027       21      1.4   ++
  100              13             3.5            -4.6            0.56           -0.87             1.8           -0.23            -1.7            -5.2            -0.3            -2.5            -4.2             4.1            -5.8         0.00035      3.6e+03     0.0027     0.95    -0.55    -
  101              14             3.3            -4.7            0.61           0.081             1.7           -0.23            -1.8            -4.8           -0.35            -2.5            -3.9               4            -5.7         0.00039      3.6e+03     0.0035     0.95     0.69    +
  102              14             3.4            -4.9            0.54          -0.095             1.6           -0.23            -1.8            -4.7           -0.37            -2.5            -3.9             3.9            -5.6         0.00042      3.6e+03     0.0013      9.5      1.4   ++
  103              14             3.4            -4.9            0.54          -0.095             1.6           -0.23            -1.8            -4.7           -0.37            -2.5            -3.9             3.9            -5.6         0.00042      3.6e+03     0.0013     0.31     -0.4    -
  104              14             3.4            -4.9            0.54          -0.095             1.6           -0.23            -1.8            -4.7           -0.37            -2.5            -3.9             3.9            -5.6         0.00042      3.6e+03     0.0013     0.15   -0.033    -
  105              14             3.4              -5            0.53            -0.1             1.5           -0.24              -2            -4.7           -0.39            -2.3              -4             3.9            -5.6         0.00047      3.6e+03     0.0025      1.5      1.2   ++
  106              14             3.4              -5            0.53            -0.1             1.5           -0.24              -2            -4.7           -0.39            -2.3              -4             3.9            -5.6         0.00047      3.6e+03     0.0025     0.36     -0.2    -
  107              14             3.6            -5.1            0.51          -0.039             1.5           -0.23              -2            -4.3           -0.33            -2.3            -4.2               4            -5.8         0.00051      3.6e+03     0.0022     0.36     0.53    +
  108              15             3.6              -5            0.51           0.069             1.3           -0.59            -2.1            -4.7           -0.37            -2.3            -4.1               4            -5.7         0.00058      3.6e+03     0.0024      3.6      1.1   ++
  109              15             3.5            -4.9            0.52            -0.1             1.2          -0.072            -2.1            -4.9           -0.35            -2.4              -4               4            -5.7         0.00066      3.6e+03    0.00087       36        1   ++
  110              15             3.5            -4.9            0.52            -0.1             1.2          -0.072            -2.1            -4.9           -0.35            -2.4              -4               4            -5.7         0.00066      3.6e+03    0.00087      1.4    -0.63    -
  111              15             3.5            -4.9            0.52            -0.1             1.2          -0.072            -2.1            -4.9           -0.35            -2.4              -4               4            -5.7         0.00066      3.6e+03    0.00087     0.72    -0.37    -
  112              16             3.7            -4.6            0.54           -0.43             1.2           -0.68              -2            -4.9           -0.22            -2.4            -4.1             4.2            -5.9         0.00081      3.6e+03     0.0022     0.72     0.64    +
  113              16             3.8            -4.6            0.48            0.26            0.96           -0.17              -2            -4.6           -0.17            -2.3            -4.1             4.2            -5.9           0.001      3.6e+03     0.0052     0.72     0.88    +
  114              16             3.8            -4.6            0.48            0.26            0.96           -0.17              -2            -4.6           -0.17            -2.3            -4.1             4.2            -5.9           0.001      3.6e+03     0.0052     0.36    -0.56    -
  115              16             3.8            -4.6            0.47           0.016            0.65           -0.13            -2.4            -4.5           -0.28            -2.6            -3.8             4.2            -5.9          0.0014      3.6e+03     0.0045     0.36      0.2    +
  116              16             3.7            -4.4            0.57           -0.23            0.99           -0.32            -2.2            -4.9           -0.22            -2.6              -4             4.2              -6          0.0013      3.6e+03     0.0054     0.36     0.58    +
  117              16             3.8            -4.5            0.56          -0.074             0.9           -0.26            -2.2            -4.8           -0.17            -2.4            -4.1             4.3              -6          0.0014      3.6e+03     0.0037      3.6      1.2   ++
  118              16             3.7            -4.6            0.55           0.005            0.78           -0.38            -2.2            -4.8           -0.18            -2.3              -4             4.2              -6          0.0018      3.6e+03     0.0045       36      1.6   ++
  119              17             3.6            -4.7            0.55           -0.15            0.68           -0.54            -2.4            -4.7           -0.26            -2.3              -4             4.2            -5.9          0.0025      3.6e+03     0.0025  3.6e+02      1.3   ++
  120              17             3.6            -4.1            0.58           -0.12            0.68           -0.36            -2.4            -4.6           -0.23            -2.3            -4.1             4.2            -5.9          0.0034      3.6e+03     0.0014  3.6e+03      1.6   ++
  121              16             3.6            -2.6            0.63           0.081            0.83           -0.41            -2.3            -3.1           -0.16            -1.5            -4.1             4.3            -6.1          0.0063      3.6e+03     0.0043  3.6e+04        1   ++
  122              17             3.6            -1.1            0.52          -0.069            0.88           -0.72            -2.2            -3.6           -0.26            -1.5            -4.2             4.2              -6          0.0088      3.6e+03      0.003  3.6e+05     0.98   ++
  123              17             3.5            -1.3             0.5           -0.13            0.97           -0.39            -2.2            -3.7           -0.32            -1.6            -4.2             4.1            -5.8           0.011      3.6e+03     0.0024  3.6e+06      1.7   ++
  124              17             3.3            -1.9            0.46           -0.58             1.4            0.43              -2            -3.4           -0.39            -1.7            -4.1             3.9            -5.6           0.019      3.6e+03     0.0022  3.6e+07      1.3   ++
  125              17             3.3            -1.9            0.46           -0.58             1.4            0.43              -2            -3.4           -0.39            -1.7            -4.1             3.9            -5.6           0.019      3.6e+03     0.0022       23      -15    -
  126              17             3.3            -1.9            0.46           -0.58             1.4            0.43              -2            -3.4           -0.39            -1.7            -4.1             3.9            -5.6           0.019      3.6e+03     0.0022       12      -16    -
  127              17             3.3            -1.9            0.46           -0.58             1.4            0.43              -2            -3.4           -0.39            -1.7            -4.1             3.9            -5.6           0.019      3.6e+03     0.0022      5.8      -16    -
  128              17             3.3            -1.9            0.46           -0.58             1.4            0.43              -2            -3.4           -0.39            -1.7            -4.1             3.9            -5.6           0.019      3.6e+03     0.0022      2.9     -7.2    -
  129              17             3.3            -1.9            0.46           -0.58             1.4            0.43              -2            -3.4           -0.39            -1.7            -4.1             3.9            -5.6           0.019      3.6e+03     0.0022      1.5     -3.3    -
  130              17             3.3            -1.9            0.46           -0.58             1.4            0.43              -2            -3.4           -0.39            -1.7            -4.1             3.9            -5.6           0.019      3.6e+03     0.0022     0.73    -0.29    -
  131              17             3.4            -1.8            0.57            -1.3             1.8            0.85            -1.8            -3.1           -0.28            -1.6            -4.2               4            -5.8            0.03      3.6e+03     0.0094     0.73     0.47    +
  132              17             3.4            -1.8            0.57            -1.3             1.8            0.85            -1.8            -3.1           -0.28            -1.6            -4.2               4            -5.8            0.03      3.6e+03     0.0094     0.36    -0.31    -
  133              17             3.6            -1.5            0.71            -1.1             1.6            0.49              -2            -3.3           -0.23            -1.7            -4.3             4.2            -6.1           0.031      3.6e+03       0.01      3.6      1.3   ++
  134              17             3.6            -1.5            0.71            -1.1             1.6            0.49              -2            -3.3           -0.23            -1.7            -4.3             4.2            -6.1           0.031      3.6e+03       0.01      1.8      -13    -
  135              17             3.6            -1.5            0.71            -1.1             1.6            0.49              -2            -3.3           -0.23            -1.7            -4.3             4.2            -6.1           0.031      3.6e+03       0.01     0.91     -8.3    -
  136              17             3.6            -1.5            0.71            -1.1             1.6            0.49              -2            -3.3           -0.23            -1.7            -4.3             4.2            -6.1           0.031      3.6e+03       0.01     0.45     -5.7    -
  137              17             3.6            -1.5            0.71            -1.1             1.6            0.49              -2            -3.3           -0.23            -1.7            -4.3             4.2            -6.1           0.031      3.6e+03       0.01     0.23     -1.5    -
  138              17             3.5            -1.6            0.68           -0.98             1.5            0.49            -1.9            -3.2           -0.28            -1.9            -4.4             4.2              -6           0.033      3.6e+03      0.012     0.23     0.17    +
  139              17             3.5            -1.6            0.59            -1.2             1.5            0.53            -1.9            -3.2           -0.21            -1.7            -4.4             4.2              -6           0.036      3.6e+03     0.0032     0.23     0.88    +
  140              17             3.7            -1.6            0.63            -1.3             1.4            0.31            -1.9            -3.4           -0.11            -1.7            -4.6             4.4            -6.2           0.039      3.6e+03     0.0026     0.23      0.4    +
  141              16             3.6            -1.5            0.63            -1.2             1.4            0.46            -1.9            -3.4           -0.15            -1.7            -4.5             4.3            -6.1           0.039      3.6e+03     0.0036      2.3      1.1   ++
  142              16             3.6            -1.5            0.63            -1.2             1.4            0.46            -1.9            -3.4           -0.15            -1.7            -4.5             4.3            -6.1           0.039      3.6e+03     0.0036      1.1     -1.4    -
  143              16             3.6            -1.5            0.63            -1.2             1.4            0.46            -1.9            -3.4           -0.15            -1.7            -4.5             4.3            -6.1           0.039      3.6e+03     0.0036     0.57    -0.89    -
  144              16             3.6            -1.5            0.63            -1.2             1.4            0.46            -1.9            -3.4           -0.15            -1.7            -4.5             4.3            -6.1           0.039      3.6e+03     0.0036     0.28     -1.2    -
  145              16             3.6            -1.5            0.63            -1.2             1.4            0.46            -1.9            -3.4           -0.15            -1.7            -4.5             4.3            -6.1           0.039      3.6e+03     0.0036     0.14    -0.37    -
  146              16             3.5            -1.5            0.62            -1.4             1.5            0.46            -1.8            -3.3           -0.15            -1.8            -4.5             4.3              -6           0.042      3.6e+03     0.0032     0.14     0.38    +
  147              16             3.5            -1.4            0.63            -1.3             1.4            0.38            -1.8            -3.3           -0.15            -1.7            -4.5             4.3            -6.1           0.043      3.6e+03     0.0011      1.4      1.4   ++
  148              15             3.5            -1.6            0.68            -1.7             1.4           -0.15            -1.8            -2.8           -0.14            -1.6            -4.5             4.3            -6.1           0.049      3.6e+03     0.0016       14      2.2   ++
  149              15             3.5            -1.6            0.68            -1.7             1.4           -0.15            -1.8            -2.8           -0.14            -1.6            -4.5             4.3            -6.1           0.049      3.6e+03     0.0016      2.2     -1.2    -
  150              15             3.5            -1.6            0.68            -1.7             1.4           -0.15            -1.8            -2.8           -0.14            -1.6            -4.5             4.3            -6.1           0.049      3.6e+03     0.0016      1.1   -0.036    -
  151              14             3.5           -0.81            0.73            -2.8             1.6            -1.1            -1.7            -2.5           -0.18            -1.8            -4.6             4.3            -6.1           0.069      3.6e+03      0.005      1.1     0.66    +
  152              13             3.5           -0.46            0.78            -3.4             1.7           -0.77            -1.7            -2.7           -0.19              -2            -4.7             4.4            -6.3           0.089      3.6e+03     0.0012      1.1     0.76    +
  153              12             3.5              -1            0.79            -2.9             1.5           -0.92            -1.8            -1.9           -0.16            -1.7            -4.7             4.4            -6.3           0.083      3.6e+03     0.0018      1.1     0.61    +
  154              11             3.4            -0.8            0.74            -2.4             1.5           -0.38            -1.9            -1.9           -0.29            -1.5            -4.6             4.3            -6.1           0.079      3.6e+03     0.0014       11      1.2   ++
  155              11             3.4            -0.8            0.74            -2.4             1.5           -0.38            -1.9            -1.9           -0.29            -1.5            -4.6             4.3            -6.1           0.079      3.6e+03     0.0014      5.6     -5.8    -
  156              11             3.4            -0.8            0.74            -2.4             1.5           -0.38            -1.9            -1.9           -0.29            -1.5            -4.6             4.3            -6.1           0.079      3.6e+03     0.0014      2.8     -1.1    -
  157              11             3.4            -0.8            0.74            -2.4             1.5           -0.38            -1.9            -1.9           -0.29            -1.5            -4.6             4.3            -6.1           0.079      3.6e+03     0.0014      1.4     -1.4    -
  158              11             3.4            -0.8            0.74            -2.4             1.5           -0.38            -1.9            -1.9           -0.29            -1.5            -4.6             4.3            -6.1           0.079      3.6e+03     0.0014      0.7     -1.1    -
  159              11             3.4            -0.8            0.74            -2.4             1.5           -0.38            -1.9            -1.9           -0.29            -1.5            -4.6             4.3            -6.1           0.079      3.6e+03     0.0014     0.35   -0.041    -
  160              11             3.4           -0.77            0.74            -2.7             1.6           -0.47            -1.9            -1.7           -0.38            -1.6            -4.6             4.3            -6.2           0.086      3.6e+03     0.0015     0.35     0.68    +
  161              10             3.4           -0.69            0.76            -2.6             1.6           -0.23              -2            -1.8           -0.38            -1.6            -4.6             4.3            -6.2           0.087      3.6e+03     0.0025      3.5     0.97   ++
  162              10             3.4           -0.69            0.76            -2.6             1.6           -0.23              -2            -1.8           -0.38            -1.6            -4.6             4.3            -6.2           0.087      3.6e+03     0.0025      1.7     -1.2    -
  163              10             3.4           -0.69            0.76            -2.6             1.6           -0.23              -2            -1.8           -0.38            -1.6            -4.6             4.3            -6.2           0.087      3.6e+03     0.0025     0.87   -0.082    -
  164             9.6             3.4           -0.48            0.76            -2.3             1.6           -0.22              -2            -1.4           -0.42            -1.3            -4.6             4.3            -6.1           0.085      3.6e+03     0.0042     0.87     0.68    +
  165             8.7             3.4           -0.73            0.77            -2.5             1.6           -0.22              -2            -1.7           -0.45            -1.4            -4.6             4.3            -6.1           0.088      3.6e+03     0.0038      8.7      1.1   ++
  166             8.7             3.4           -0.73            0.77            -2.5             1.6           -0.22              -2            -1.7           -0.45            -1.4            -4.6             4.3            -6.1           0.088      3.6e+03     0.0038      1.6     -1.9    -
  167             8.7             3.4           -0.73            0.77            -2.5             1.6           -0.22              -2            -1.7           -0.45            -1.4            -4.6             4.3            -6.1           0.088      3.6e+03     0.0038     0.81    -0.59    -
  168             7.9             3.5            -1.5            0.84            -2.9             1.7            0.07            -2.1              -2           -0.42            -1.7            -4.9             4.5            -6.6             0.1      3.6e+03     0.0061      8.1      1.2   ++
  169             7.9             3.5            -1.5            0.84            -2.9             1.7            0.07            -2.1              -2           -0.42            -1.7            -4.9             4.5            -6.6             0.1      3.6e+03     0.0061        4      -18    -
  170             7.9             3.5            -1.5            0.84            -2.9             1.7            0.07            -2.1              -2           -0.42            -1.7            -4.9             4.5            -6.6             0.1      3.6e+03     0.0061        2     -3.9    -
  171             7.9             3.5            -1.5            0.84            -2.9             1.7            0.07            -2.1              -2           -0.42            -1.7            -4.9             4.5            -6.6             0.1      3.6e+03     0.0061        1     -1.4    -
  172             6.9             3.4            -1.6            0.81            -3.2             1.7         -0.0093            -2.1            -2.2           -0.51            -1.8            -4.8             4.4            -6.4            0.11      3.6e+03     0.0085        1     0.17    +
  173             6.9             3.4            -1.6            0.81            -3.2             1.7         -0.0093            -2.1            -2.2           -0.51            -1.8            -4.8             4.4            -6.4            0.11      3.6e+03     0.0085      0.5     -1.1    -
  174             6.8             3.2            -1.1            0.76            -2.8             1.6            0.28            -2.2            -1.7           -0.59            -1.5            -4.6             4.2            -6.1             0.1      3.6e+03      0.014      0.5     0.89    +
  175             6.7             3.5            -1.6            0.76            -2.4             1.5            0.26            -2.3            -1.7           -0.49            -1.3            -4.7             4.4            -6.5             0.1      3.6e+03      0.015      0.5     0.52    +
  176             6.5             3.5            -1.6            0.72            -2.9             1.3          0.0081            -2.4            -1.6           -0.53            -1.2            -4.7             4.2            -6.5            0.12      3.6e+03      0.012        5      1.1   ++
  177             6.5             3.5            -1.6            0.72            -2.9             1.3          0.0081            -2.4            -1.6           -0.53            -1.2            -4.7             4.2            -6.5            0.12      3.6e+03      0.012      2.5     -2.8    -
  178             6.5             3.5            -1.6            0.72            -2.9             1.3          0.0081            -2.4            -1.6           -0.53            -1.2            -4.7             4.2            -6.5            0.12      3.6e+03      0.012      1.3    -0.14    -
  179             5.2             3.3            -1.7            0.72            -2.6            0.84            0.79            -2.7           -0.91           -0.69           -0.91            -4.5             3.7            -6.3            0.14      3.5e+03      0.011      1.3     0.17    +
  180             4.5             3.3            -2.2            0.67            -2.5            0.71            0.21            -2.7            -1.3           -0.65           -0.76            -4.4             3.4            -6.1            0.13      3.5e+03      0.019       13     0.91   ++
  181             4.5             3.3            -2.2            0.67            -2.5            0.71            0.21            -2.7            -1.3           -0.65           -0.76            -4.4             3.4            -6.1            0.13      3.5e+03      0.019      1.6     -5.2    -
  182             4.5             3.3            -2.2            0.67            -2.5            0.71            0.21            -2.7            -1.3           -0.65           -0.76            -4.4             3.4            -6.1            0.13      3.5e+03      0.019     0.79    -0.22    -
  183             4.4             3.6              -3            0.73            -2.6            0.69            0.12            -2.4            -1.1           -0.44            -0.6            -4.5             3.2            -6.4            0.14      3.5e+03      0.013     0.79     0.26    +
  184             4.2             3.5            -3.8            0.93            -3.2             1.1            0.73            -2.2           -0.96           -0.38           -0.84            -4.8             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03     0.0036     0.79     0.51    +
  185               5             3.2            -3.6            0.92              -3             1.2            0.81            -2.2            -1.3           -0.44            -1.2            -4.5             3.4            -6.5            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0047     0.79     0.81    +
  186             4.9             3.2              -4            0.98            -2.9             1.1             1.6            -2.1            -1.3           -0.27            -1.3            -4.6             3.4            -6.7            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0054     0.79     0.75    +
  187             4.9             3.2              -4            0.98            -2.9             1.1             1.6            -2.1            -1.3           -0.27            -1.3            -4.6             3.4            -6.7            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0054     0.39     -1.2    -
  188             4.9             3.2              -4            0.98            -2.9             1.1             1.6            -2.1            -1.3           -0.27            -1.3            -4.6             3.4            -6.7            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0054      0.2    0.039    -
  189               5             3.1            -4.2            0.92              -3             1.2             1.5            -2.1            -1.1           -0.26            -1.2            -4.4             3.4            -6.8            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0014      0.2     0.69    +
  190             5.2             3.1            -4.1            0.93            -2.9             1.3             1.6            -2.1            -1.2           -0.26            -1.2            -4.5             3.4            -6.7            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0014        2     0.93   ++
  191             5.2             3.1            -4.1            0.93            -2.9             1.3             1.6            -2.1            -1.2           -0.26            -1.2            -4.5             3.4            -6.7            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0014     0.98       -3    -
  192             5.2             3.1            -4.1            0.93            -2.9             1.3             1.6            -2.1            -1.2           -0.26            -1.2            -4.5             3.4            -6.7            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0014     0.49    -0.31    -
  193             5.4               3            -4.6             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.1            -1.9            -1.2           -0.17            -1.4            -4.5             3.3            -6.7            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0018     0.49     0.68    +
  194             5.4               3            -4.6             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.1            -1.9            -1.2           -0.17            -1.4            -4.5             3.3            -6.7            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0018     0.25    -0.91    -
  195             5.3             3.1            -4.7               1            -2.6             1.4             2.2            -1.9            -1.2           -0.17            -1.3            -4.5             3.4            -6.9            0.15      3.5e+03    0.00076     0.25      0.9    +
  196             5.3             3.1            -4.7               1            -2.6             1.4             2.2            -1.9            -1.2           -0.17            -1.3            -4.5             3.4            -6.9            0.15      3.5e+03    0.00076     0.12    -0.14    -
  197             5.3             3.1            -4.8               1            -2.7             1.4             2.1              -2            -1.3           -0.24            -1.4            -4.5             3.5            -6.9            0.15      3.5e+03      0.001     0.12     0.74    +
  198             5.3             3.1            -4.8               1            -2.6             1.5             2.2              -2            -1.3           -0.21            -1.5            -4.5             3.5            -6.9            0.15      3.5e+03    0.00074     0.12     0.61    +
  199             5.3             3.1              -5               1            -2.6             1.4             2.2              -2            -1.4            -0.2            -1.5            -4.6             3.4            -6.9            0.15      3.5e+03    0.00089     0.12      0.7    +
  200             5.4             3.1              -5               1            -2.7             1.4             2.2              -2            -1.4           -0.19            -1.5            -4.5             3.5            -6.9            0.15      3.5e+03      0.001      1.2     0.96   ++
  201             5.4             3.1              -5               1            -2.7             1.4             2.2              -2            -1.4           -0.19            -1.5            -4.5             3.5            -6.9            0.15      3.5e+03      0.001     0.61     -5.8    -
  202             5.9             3.1            -5.6             1.1            -2.7             1.4             2.2              -2            -1.6           -0.12            -1.7            -4.5             3.4              -7            0.15      3.5e+03      0.003     0.61     0.69    +
  203             5.9             3.1            -5.6             1.1            -2.7             1.4             2.2              -2            -1.6           -0.12            -1.7            -4.5             3.4              -7            0.15      3.5e+03      0.003     0.31     -5.8    -
  204             5.9             3.1            -5.6             1.1            -2.7             1.4             2.2              -2            -1.6           -0.12            -1.7            -4.5             3.4              -7            0.15      3.5e+03      0.003     0.15       -1    -
  205               6             3.1            -5.7             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.3              -2            -1.6           -0.12            -1.8            -4.6             3.5              -7            0.16      3.5e+03     0.0028     0.15     0.25    +
  206               6             3.1            -5.7             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.3              -2            -1.6           -0.12            -1.8            -4.6             3.5              -7            0.16      3.5e+03     0.0028    0.077    -0.46    -
  207               6             3.1            -5.7             1.1            -2.8             1.4             2.3              -2            -1.7           -0.14            -1.7            -4.6             3.5              -7            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0017     0.77      1.1   ++
  208               6             3.1            -5.7             1.1            -2.8             1.4             2.3              -2            -1.7           -0.14            -1.7            -4.6             3.5              -7            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0017     0.16     -3.2    -
  209             6.1             3.1            -5.8             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.3              -2            -1.7           -0.13            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.9            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0013     0.16      0.7    +
  210             6.1             3.1            -5.8             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.3              -2            -1.7           -0.13            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.9            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0013    0.078     -2.2    -
  211             6.1             3.1            -5.8             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.3              -2            -1.7           -0.13            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.9            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0013    0.039    0.019    -
  212             6.1             3.1            -5.9               1            -2.9             1.4             2.3              -2            -1.7           -0.16            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.9            0.15      3.5e+03     0.0011    0.039     0.88    +
  213             6.1             3.1            -5.9               1            -2.9             1.4             2.3              -2            -1.7           -0.17            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.9            0.16      3.5e+03    0.00041     0.39      1.5   ++
  214             6.1             3.1            -5.9               1            -2.9             1.4             2.3              -2            -1.7           -0.17            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.9            0.16      3.5e+03    0.00041     0.19       -8    -
  215             6.1             3.1            -5.9               1            -2.9             1.4             2.3              -2            -1.7           -0.17            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.9            0.16      3.5e+03    0.00041    0.097     -3.4    -
  216             6.1             3.1            -5.9               1            -2.9             1.4             2.3              -2            -1.7           -0.17            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.9            0.16      3.5e+03    0.00041    0.049    -0.28    -
  217             6.2               3            -5.9             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.4              -2            -1.7           -0.17            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03     0.0004    0.049     0.66    +
  218             6.2             3.1            -5.9             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.3              -2            -1.7           -0.16            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03     0.0004    0.049     0.16    +
  219             6.2             3.1              -6               1            -2.9             1.4             2.4              -2            -1.7           -0.21            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03     0.0003    0.049     0.29    +
  220             6.2             3.1              -6             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.4              -2            -1.7           -0.16            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03    0.00018    0.049     0.54    +
  221             6.2             3.1              -6             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.4              -2            -1.7           -0.16            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03    0.00018    0.024 -9.6e-05    -
  222             6.2             3.1              -6             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.4              -2            -1.7           -0.17            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03    0.00017    0.024     0.74    +
  223             6.3             3.1              -6             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.4              -2            -1.7           -0.17            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03    0.00017     0.24      1.1   ++
  224             6.3             3.1              -6             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.4              -2            -1.7           -0.17            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03    0.00017     0.12     -3.1    -
  225             6.3             3.1              -6             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.4              -2            -1.7           -0.17            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03    0.00017    0.061     -1.1    -
  226             6.3             3.1              -6             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.4              -2            -1.7           -0.17            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03    0.00017     0.03  -0.0069    -
  227             6.3               3            -6.1             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.4              -2            -1.7           -0.17            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03    0.00017     0.03     0.65    +
  228             6.3             3.1            -6.1             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.4              -2            -1.8           -0.17            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03    0.00017     0.03     0.76    +
  229             6.3             3.1            -6.1             1.1            -2.9             1.4             2.4              -2            -1.8           -0.17            -1.8            -4.5             3.4            -6.8            0.16      3.5e+03    7.3e-05     0.03     0.44    +
Results saved in file b15panel_discrete_bis.html
Results saved in file b15panel_discrete_bis.pickle
print(results.short_summary())
Results for model b15panel_discrete_bis
Nbr of parameters:              15
Sample size:                    752
Observations:                   6768
Excluded data:                  3960
Final log likelihood:           -3538.404
Akaike Information Criterion:   7106.808
Bayesian Information Criterion: 7176.149
pandas_results = results.get_estimated_parameters()
pandas_results
Value Rob. Std err Rob. t-test Rob. p-value
ASC_CAR_S_class0 6.282044 1.229897 5.107782 3.259619e-07
ASC_CAR_S_class1 3.047664 0.416991 7.308700 2.697842e-13
ASC_CAR_class0 -6.063924 1.307709 -4.637058 3.534031e-06
ASC_CAR_class1 1.060771 0.273793 3.874360 1.069053e-04
ASC_SM_S_class0 -2.913725 0.598062 -4.871943 1.105060e-06
ASC_SM_S_class1 1.405215 0.727443 1.931719 5.339419e-02
ASC_TRAIN_S_class0 2.367597 0.441171 5.366618 8.022673e-08
ASC_TRAIN_S_class1 -1.976041 0.333127 -5.931798 2.996354e-09
ASC_TRAIN_class0 -1.742296 0.535984 -3.250651 1.151413e-03
ASC_TRAIN_class1 -0.169658 0.355672 -0.477007 6.333571e-01
B_COST_class0 -1.838490 0.412350 -4.458563 8.251082e-06
B_COST_class1 -4.478209 0.375484 -11.926492 0.000000e+00
B_TIME_S_class1 3.409308 0.397240 8.582495 0.000000e+00
B_TIME_class1 -6.843361 0.542668 -12.610587 0.000000e+00
prob_class0 0.163814 0.026522 6.176553 6.551608e-10


Total running time of the script: (4 minutes 9.944 seconds)

Gallery generated by Sphinx-Gallery